
Dubai, Abu Dhabi or Qatar? The Gulf states, ranked and rated
Gulf States: From Desert to Destination
The astonishing transformation of the Gulf states into premier luxury travel destinations is nothing short of extraordinary. A long-time Indian expat put it aptly: in under 50 years, these countries have leapt “from donkeys to Aston Martins.” That sentiment captures the essence of their progress. Dubai, Abu Dhabi, and Qatar have evolved from barren desert outposts to polished, modern hubs offering a wealth of attractions, gourmet dining, and, at least during the winter, ideal weather.
In this trio, Dubai plays the role of a flamboyant Las Vegas, Abu Dhabi resembles a more measured Washington D.C., and Qatar presents itself as a refined, if somewhat reserved, contender eager to win affection through lavish spending. But which of these Gulf states truly stands out—either as a long-haul layover or a full-fledged holiday destination? Let’s explore how they compare across key categories like accommodation, cuisine, activities, and airline connectivity.
Air Travel and Connectivity
Any discussion of the Gulf must begin with its world-renowned airlines. Emirates (Dubai), Etihad (Abu Dhabi), and Qatar Airways (Doha) consistently rank among the globe’s elite carriers, known for their state-of-the-art fleets and impeccable in-flight service. In fact, it's often joked that gaining employment with Emirates is more competitive than getting into Harvard.
While Emirates once led the pack unequivocally—an opinion still held by many—the standards of Qatar Airways now rival, and perhaps surpass, it, especially considering Doha’s ultra-luxurious Hamad International Airport. Etihad, although slightly behind, remains a top-tier choice.
So strong are these airlines that increasing numbers of travellers between the UK and South Africa are choosing to connect via Gulf cities, sometimes turning these stopovers into brief exploratory visits.
Dubai: Glittering and Grand
Celebrating 25 years since its opening, the sail-shaped Burj Al Arab Jumeirah remains an emblem of Dubai’s extravagant vision. Despite its £1,000-per-night suites and steady influx of touring groups, a night here is an experience worth considering.
Nearby, the Madinat Jumeirah complex combines four luxurious hotels—Dar Al Masyaf, Al Qasr, Al Naseem, and Mina A’Salam—linked by serene waterways navigable via traditional abra boats. It’s a more resort-style take on Dubai luxury, with rooms starting around £262.
For family-oriented comfort, The Westin on Jumeirah Beach offers excellent five-star value from £216 a night. It shares its beachfront with Le Meridien and the adults-only W The Palm, and features the new Jungle Bay waterpark along with generously sized beachfront rooms.
Abu Dhabi: Tranquil Elegance
Though it may lack Dubai’s towering skyline, Abu Dhabi compensates with peaceful, beachfront resorts beloved by British visitors.
The Jumeirah at Saadiyat Island boasts 293 rooms on a pristine stretch of beach, often visited by dolphins and turtles. With a blend of Italian, Arabic, and Levantine dining options, and ocean-view rooms starting at £333, it’s a tranquil and indulgent escape.
Next door, the Rotana Saadiyat Island offers a vast resort experience with 327 rooms and 13 beach villas. Featuring seven restaurants—including the standout Italian spot, Si—and a palm-shaded pool by the sand, it offers a luxe stay from £146 per night.
On Yas Island, the architecturally striking W hotel provides a unique vantage point: it’s built directly over the Formula 1 racetrack. Comprising two towers linked by a steel-and-glass bridge, the hotel’s interior is as remarkable as its location. A stay here begins at £239, with beach transfers available. The in-house spa is highly praised—ask for Kanya, whose Thai massage skills are unforgettable.
Emirates Palace, now operating under the Mandarin Oriental brand since 2023, has added a top-tier spa and introduced the region’s first vegan-friendly rooms.
Qatar: Sophisticated Splendour

Qatar steals the spotlight in the hotel stakes, thanks to the architectural and experiential marvel that is the Fairmont and Raffles twin towers in the Katara District. Shaped like two crossed scimitars, this development has become Qatar’s signature landmark, much like the Burj Al Arab for Dubai.
Inside one tower, the Raffles offers only suites—starting at 700 square feet—and delivers opulence at its finest. Expect high ceilings, lavish materials, and personalised service, including a dedicated butler who remembers your preferred sundown cocktail. Rates start around £389.
Not far away, and adjacent to the vibrant Katara Cultural Village, is The Chedi Katara. This refined beachside property offers 59 rooms and 32 villas styled with Mughal and Ottoman influences. With chilled pools to beat the summer heat and direct access to cultural venues, rooms begin at £308.
Other high-end competitors include The Ned (£262), St Regis Doha (£295), InterContinental Residences (£474), and the overwater Anantara resort on Banana Island, reachable via a 30-minute boat ride from Doha (from £367).